I prefer Keen Commuters on my BMX pedals without cleats. I tried them in spinning class with cleats and found they were collapsing a bit around the pedal. Perhaps it was just this particular pair, but I didn't care for it. I've ridden up to 75 miles with the Keens on BMX pedals, so it hasn't been a problem. The cleats didn't last long enough on the Keens last summer for me to try them on the real bike.