Well, our 5 brooks saddles were all bought over a period of 4 years or so, and for much less than a hundred bucks each...two of them were bought used. Not $500, more like $350 for two people, spread over 4 years. No big whoop considering how many serial saddles some folks buy. The best part is that Brooks saddles often last for more than 20, or even 30 years, unlike plastic and padded or gel saddles. i had to sell two B17's when I realized I really needed the wider B68 for my two bikes. But when it fits well, it'll last forever. Brooks can be bought used at a good savings, and because they are so incredibly durable it's better than when you buy most other saddles used.