Thanks for y'all's help and advice. I swung by a couple of shops today. One shop, I just didn't feel like the guy was listening to me and they had very little in stock. After talking with second shop (I really liked this places staff) they said that given my love of my road bike, they feel I'd be better suited to a hybrid. Right now they are recommending a Cannondale Quick. Because I'm short (4'11"), they are building one of the extra small's out for me to come back and test ride on Friday.
I am googling tonight to find the nearest Trek dealer and hopefully I can check them out this week as well.
Thanks again and I will keep you posted (and check out the blog)