I have a 2004 Jeep Liberty and I love it. I can get a lot of stuff in it with the seats down, it has great 4x4, and it's really fun to drive. The gas mileage is not good (especially now that's gas is skyrocketing) and it drives like a truck - not the smooth car-like ride others offer. I had most of your vehicles on my list as well and I ended up with the Jeep because of a great deal. I also liked the Honda CR-V and I know several people who've had great luck with newer Kias.
2009 Surly Cross Check
2003 Cannondale Bad Boy
Motobecane Nobly (60's or 70's)