35 F is what, 1-2 deg. C? This is what I wear for those temps, good for an hours brisk ride:

top: shortsleeved wicking underwear or wool, winter softshell jacket
bottom: bike shorts, PI Amfib winter tights
head: helmet cap, pref. windproof, Buff or neck gaiter
hands: lined XC skiing gloves
feet: medium-weight wool socks, winter cycling boots

For rides longer than an hour I'd wear longsleeved wool and try not to get it too sweaty, and add a windproof vest.

This may not help much if you own very different clothing, but the principle is pretty simple - cover almost all exposed skin with a thin layer of wool or something wicking (i.e. not cotton), add windproof, heavy footwear and gloves, and keep your head warm.