I developed a rash on my eyelids more than 20 years ago after using a gray eyeliner. It was a brand that was supposed to be hypoallergenic. After that I stopped wearing eyeshadow or colored eyeliners. It wasn't worth the expense and irritation of the trial and error required to find products that wouldn't cause problems.

In the past couple of months I've bought one of the Almay trios and a few of their Pure Blends shadows. The skin under my eyes is looking older so I thought eyeshadow might help brighten things. None of them has caused a rash, but a couple of them irritate my eyes a bit. I don't really like the colors, either.