Your opinions on these trainers?

[LilBolt]

For the mat, we purchased the inexpensive carpet runner by the linear foot from one of the home improvement stores. I haven't used the trainers that you are considering, but give another vote for the Kurt Kinetic.

[abejita]

Another vote for Kurt Kinetics...we got the rock and roll this fall and love it!

[Becky]

We have two Cycle Ops trainers, one of which is 10 years old and still going strong! I've been pleased with both its durability and their customer service.

Some general thoughts:
Remote shifters annoy me. One more thing to fuss with and little benefit, IMO.
If you can, ride different brands and models first. I've ridden some that I've hated and others that I loved. They're not all the same...
Pay close attention to how the bike mounts in the trainer and how easy it is to use. You're going to use that lever/knob a lot! Something that requires turning a knob multiple times to anchor the bike quickly gets old.

Have fun shopping!