Lake Freeride shoes and Five Tens

I keep reading how "grippy" these shoes are, and the reviews make it sound like some have found that they can even pull up on the pedals when they use these with BMX pedals - I assume from the pins getting seated in the rubber.

This would actually be a bad thing for me - has anyone had any experience with this actually happening? Sounds a bit far to me, but I can't afford to purchase either shoe and find this happens. The entire point to returning to BMX pedals until spring is to give my hamstrings a break until there is no doubt that they are healed. Riding with platform pedals does not hurt. Clipping in does. Therefore I won't be clipping in

I just wanted to check one more time, I need to pull the trigger on something soon as my new pedals will be here Friday and I need something to put on my feet to ride in that will be flat & stiff enough Somehow I think it's a little cool for my Keen Commuters...Am also tempted by PI Trail shoes, but wonder if the grooves are too deep for the pins to get good contact...