I just bought my first pair as well. I tried on several first with the idea that if they weren't comfortable walking around the store, they weren't going to feel any better on the bike.

That worked well for me. I found pairs in both men's and women's and ended up with a pair of women's Specialized Mtb in a size a bit larger than I usually wear. I spent about $130 on them. I couldn't afford anything more after the bike and the fitting.

But they are very comfortable, a great fit and I'm SO glad I went clipless and got these shoes.

No more numb toes. I'm loving them. Happy shopping!