I have a question, when you say "biked myself out of them" do you mean they wore out, or that you're now a different kind of rider?
If they just wore out, but you loved them when they were new, I'd get the same ones.
They're now a size too big. They were probably a touch too large when I first got them, but not enough for me to notice. I looked at replacing them, but apparently they've been discontinued.