Because Melissa bought my Mom’s bike (see both the Show Us Your Mixte thread and the For Sale thread for “before” images), I’m eager to help her. My Mom also is enjoying the updates, knowing a happy rider will be the end result.
That said, my knowledge is big steel from before 1985. Thus, I can advise her about the French thread issues of the BB (Velo Orange is clearly the best, although not cheapest, solution), headset and hub/freewheel, but I ain’t much use on the specific choices she needs to make now. Please help!
The crank choice is her first need. I’ll help (I hope) by adding questions.
Crank arm length. Melissa is, like many riders here, not tall. Should she be looking at shorter crank arms? Like, say, 165 or 167.5? Or stick with the easily available 170?
She’s decided that a single front crank will be adequate for her gear range, so the search is really for a nice, inexpensive, but very sharp looking single chain ring crank. I’ve seen some nice ones in the photos here. Who can suggest a specific choice? (That Ebay one is terrible!)
Chain ring size? If she’s going with only one, and only a 5- or 6-speed freewheel (due to the limits of the old frame and original French hub), should she go 42, 46, or what?
Once the right crankset is found, she can order a bottom bracket with the right spindle length to match. If the crankset suggestions come with known spindle requirements, do please suggest that, too.
Then comes the derailleur choice. I’ve suggested she should pick something strong & sturdy, but not their most expensive, from the Suntour or Shimano stable. Something that can handle a wider range of gears, so she can experiment later with wider freewheel options.
Again, I know the idea, but don’t know which RD would best fit that description now. Suggestions?
THEN, what shifter? I’d think a nice thumb shifter that can be at handlebar height would be nice for the townie conversion, but this is entirely my fancy. Advice and suggestions for her would be appreciated.
Anyway, I hope this helps expand on the initial questions. Melissa and I have swapped a bunch of messages, but she’s exceeded my knowledge bandwidth for these choices.
I’ve received lots of great advice here. Please help on this one. Thanks from me.
Owen