Thanks for all the replies! No, I avoided those "warming" ingredients because I did not want to be "warmed" or "cooled" down there for any reason lol. I checked my label and it says beeswax, mineral oil, lanolin. So it may be one of the other ingredients? Regardless, I am not able to use that any more.

Any suggestions on things that ARE non-irritating and don't involve talc or other irritants?