Hey ladies, here's a little update on how all this turned out. Hertz Claims Management wrote me a check for $1,400 for repairs without batting an eye. They also agreed to pay for the cost of the rental bike, although I doubt any of us imagined that it would take 6 weeks for me to get my bicycle back repaired (I haven't gotten reimbursed for that $985 charge, so this matter isn't completely resolved yet. Also I have an ongoing issue with the shop that did the work, but that doesn't stop me from riding the bike). It's taken another 2 weeks since then to actually get it back into 100% enjoyable-to-ride condition. I

Here's how it turned out after the repairs:









The work included: a Davidson fork painted to match the fenders; a new Terry Donna Butterfly saddle; a new left-side crank arm; a new front wheel; new pedals; and replacing the broken carbon bars with an old aluminum set I already had. The new wheel and crank arm don't match the old ones because colors have changed since I built the bike originally.

Overall I'm satisfied so far. I'm not totally happy with the results because of the mismatching, the terrible customer service at the shop that did the work, and the outstanding rental bike cost. But I have my bike back for Bike to Work Week, so I'm not complaining.