Do you need a cut-out? (If you're sitting on a hard flat surface and leaning forward with your legs raised so you're sort of in riding position, do your soft parts get squished?)

I need a cut-out, and I'm pretty happy with my Jett. But cut-outs can cause problems for some people.

Also, the Jett is harder than many saddles, but it still has some squishiness. If you want less of that, a Spec' Ruby might be a better comparison to a Brooks... but nothing on a plastic frame is really going to compare with the feel of tensioned leather, either.

If you order direct from Specialized, they have a 30-day return policy. There's a Brooks dealer that a lot of TE'rs deal with (Wallingford?) that has an extended return policy, also.