I'm a big fan of the Shebeest Shindigger, which lands just below the knee and has no Elastic of Death, as Lisa so colorfully put it! I also like not getting the big-time tan line that comes with a standard bike short. The chamois is just about right, too. (For me.) Fits well, no diaper butt. I'm 5'3" and about 118 lbs.

I haven't worn a skirt over mine, but the Shindigger might look pretty cute with one of the Sheila Moon ballet minis or a short reversible Terry skirt.......A plain black wrapper skirt might be oh-so-chic as well.