I'm agonizing over the same thing, but for different reasons. Need another car for SilverDaughter. Here's what I'm finding:

- Started looking for Rav4/CR-V - mileage stinks
- I only buy used...but no one is buy new, so used supply is tight (and precious$)
- In "bang for the buck", is the difference between an '07 30mpg Civic for $11,000 and an '07 45mph Prius for $21,000 worth it...not for someone who doesn't drive much
- Here's what I'm liking for her right now:
- Scion xB
- The new Kia SOUL - it's funky hip - albeit new and unproven
- Honda Accord/Civic

It is odd right now that with used supplies down, some new cars may wind up being a better deal than the most popular used models.

Good luck - let us know which way you go.