Hi,
really more than answers I have questions first
Were those two the only bikes available to try - or did you test ride many and narrow down to those two as the ones that fit you best?
Also - this is mainly curiosity but what makes you choose a compact? I figure 34-50 so did you like this better than 39-53 or is it for another reason, and what cassette would you have in the back - is it the same for both bikes?
Last question - please ignore it if it sounds unpolite, really it is not meant to- but are you in Houston, TX and if yes which shop are you test-riding at?