Hi,
I have always been very skeptical about learning from books, DVDs, CDs...
Of course here is my disclaimerand is that I may be biased as I practiced Martial Arts for like 25 years, and used to teach for about six. The way I see Martial Arts - philosophy and spirituality are an essential component of the learning process, and this component is very hard to convey through a DVD or a book without the individual interaction with a teacher. The same I could say about Yoga: you could not become a practicioner of Yoga using a book or a video. You can learn the technical aspect of the movement, but that does not make you a practitioner. In other words, you can watch a video about surgery and practice many times - but it would not make you a physician, right? Well, this is sort of the same process.
There is much more to this training than merely movement and physical conditioning. It is a process of growth that really benefits from having a teacher, a mentor. Depending on the art you chose, he/she may be called Kru, Shidoshi, Master, Sifu, or any other way - but you really need guidance to learn and improve.
That said, there are good books and good videos about Martial Arts, as there are good ones about Yoga. But the way I see it - you can only benefit from them if they come as a complement to your training.
Not knowing your area, and knowing close to nothing of Tai Chi, I can only offer general advice, but feel free to PM if you want to know more and I can find an answer asking more experienced people.
Look around in your area and go explore several schools. If budget is a problem, you can still go visit the schools, observe a couple of classes, and then sit for a meeting with the owner of the school you would like to work with - and ask for alternative options. Offer your help in exchange for training.
From my personal experience Martial Arts practitioners are usually very open to alternative solutions. I had a few students who could not afford lessons and decided to volunteer in the gym in exchange for their training, by simply donating a few hours to help clean, organize, answer the phone, prepare advertisements or flyers, etc. I had volunteered myself for my teacher in a time of financial hardship, and so did many of my friends.
The world of Martial Arts is, generally speaking very collaborative, and we take pride in giving good example of leadership through Martial Arts. Most of the teachers wil try to help if they see that you are really motivated to learn.
One last small advice, if you are new to Martial Arts, look around and take your time to explore. If you decide for Art A and no one teaches A in your area, do not give up and solely rely on books just to stick with the Art of your choice. If someone nearby teaches B and C - then give B or C a try. You can always move to a different art or go back to A later - and you will do so with a more open mind and with invaluable experience. Many of us have practiced different Martial Arts and different styles, some of us cross-trained on purpose, and there is no training that is ever wasted: we learn from each and every one.
Best of luck
![]()




and is that I may be biased as I practiced Martial Arts for like 25 years, and used to teach for about six. The way I see Martial Arts - philosophy and spirituality are an essential component of the learning process, and this component is very hard to convey through a DVD or a book without the individual interaction with a teacher. The same I could say about Yoga: you could not become a practicioner of Yoga using a book or a video. You can learn the technical aspect of the movement, but that does not make you a practitioner. In other words, you can watch a video about surgery and practice many times - but it would not make you a physician, right? Well, this is sort of the same process.
Reply With Quote