Just today I replaced my 6,000-miles old Terry Butterfly with...drum roll...another Terry Butterfly! I'm really happy with this saddle and I would recommend it, although saddles are such a personal thing that it's virtually impossible to know what will work for someone else. I would love to try a Brooks but I'll need to plan ahead better next time. This was an unanticipated saddle replacement as a rail was coming loose. Since I'm doing a Century on the 26th (well, supposedly I'm doing a Century...we'll see), I wanted to stick with something I know will be ok.