One Reason Cyclists Are Disliked

[Thorn]

I have to ask - those of you who categorically state you will not go through a red light - what do you do when the light won't change and there's no pedestrian button?

I legally (in Wisconsin) proceed after counting to 45 yielding to traffic in the intersection

I don't think anyone here is advocating BLOWING a stoplight or stop sign. We've all seen people do it and most of us have done it at one time or another, but it's pretty much impossible to justify.

In this thread, we're talking about rolling stops with zero forward velocity, and/or going through a red light after a complete foot-down stop. Either of those is completely different from just ignoring the traffic signal.

Yep...interesting the thread started with blantant disregard of traffic signals, but has turned into an argument of rolling. These are the same arguments for/against the Idaho stop -- rolling stop signs and stop and proceed at red lights.

People get all charged up because they don't differentiate between the blantant disregard of signals (we can probably all agree is wrong) and the respect of a slow roll through a stop that yields to traffic that has the ROW (something that most of us do whether we admit it or not).

[Crankin]

Oakleaf, I was faced with blatant disregard of red lights on my old commute. It was 6:15 AM, so not a lot of traffic. The first situation required stopping at a residential street that crosses a busy state highway. There is also a left turn arrow, for traffic on the highway. There's a detector thing, but it doesn't get triggered by my bike. I would wait for another car to come, but the first time, I didn't make it across the highway before the light turned yellow. So, from then on, I started across when I saw the traffic on the highway get the yellow and I clearly saw no cars coming. The second one is a T intersection that's on a little uphill, where I had to turn left. I have trouble navigating these for whatever reasons. Again, my bike doesn't trigger the sensor, but there was more traffic here. If no cars were coming, I went through the red. Sometimes my boss would pass me on her way to work, but thankfully, she never saw this...
I would never blatantly blow a light or stop sign. I have seen this plenty of times. Once my dh did it and I told him I would never ride with him again! It worked.

[Aint Doody]

Going back to my OP--If you were right behind me along with 2 others in single file, would you pass me ON THE RIGHT after I have signaled a stop and yelled, "Stopping"? Remember--there was a truck approaching from the left. Her husband told me this morning that she told him I was mad at her. Maybe I am, but it's because she potentially gave the entire group a black eye. More like I'm annoyed with her decision.

[katluvr]

Going back to my OP--If you were right behind me along with 2 others in single file, would you pass me ON THE RIGHT after I have signaled a stop and yelled, "Stopping"? Remember--there was a truck approaching from the left. Her husband told me this morning that she told him I was mad at her. Maybe I am, but it's because she potentially gave the entire group a black eye. More like I'm annoyed with her decision.

You are right...you were in front and communicated the stopping.
I agree w/ almost everything said in this thread. I avoid a lot of groups d/t the blowing thru. I also think there is a diff between ignoring lights/stop signs and the slowing down or "rolling stop".
I gues this is how I handle it:
Stop signs = rolling stop at times.
Traffic lights = stopping but w/some exceptions...early morning when the light DOES not or WILL not change and I can truly assess the situation. We have a small downtime w/ lots of one way streets...fairly easy to assess.
Does this equal "obeying" traffic laws? Proably not, no more than pedestrians that WALK with the Do Not Walk sign flashing or don't cross at corners/intersctions/cross walks.

But I do try and do think I am safe. Safer than most.

[Aint Doody]

I agree with Katluvr's actions. That's what I do, too. (And I jay-walk!)

[katluvr]

I agree with Katluvr's actions. That's what I do, too. (And I jay-walk!)

Jay-walking OMG!
I am sure you slow down and assess the situation fully!

I think we all agree here it is that blatant disregard for traffic signs/signals that the problem AND DOES give all of us a bad reputation!

[OakLeaf]

I think we all agree here it is that blatant disregard for traffic signs/signals that the problem AND DOES give all of us a bad reputation!

Yep.

[crazycanuck]

I'm too chicken to go through a stop sign after about 630am . If it's 530 am or so, Ã*'ll just do a rolling peek & go through. This all depends on the road of course!!

Traffic lights..I aim to set myself on the line where the sensors are. I wasn't aware of this until someone mentioned that if you place yourself on the cracked lines at the lights, green light!

Since I normally ride on my own, I am not about to make a fool of myself!

Another thing that irritates me is cyclists with no rear lights.

While i'm here, i have another complaint. I am frustrated with VERY bright blinky front lights...Geez, if you're cycling along a path towards or behind other cyclists, can you turn them to normal mode? OW..it hurts me eyes & don''t appreciate it at 6am. (as a motorist as well..)

C

[Mr. Bloom]

I think we all agree here it is that blatant disregard for traffic signs/signals that the problem AND DOES give all of us a bad reputation!

...and so does spandex

Oops, was that a hi-jack?