Based on the recommendations here, I decided to order a Selle San Marco Atola Gelaround saddle (found it at Colorado Cyclist for $69.99, most other stores that carried it were in the UK). I have been riding Terry Butterflies for years but think the back is too wide; I get lots of chafing towards the back. Love the cutout and general feel of the saddle. I wanted to try a narrower saddle but one that was not too incredibly hard (I tried the Terry Damselfly and OWWWW....way too hard, and the cutout was too narrow and pinched!) I chose the Atola Gelaround over the regular Atola since it sounded like it would be a bit softer in the sitbone area. So I'll report back once it comes in and I can try it out!

Do those of you who have the Atola have the regular model or the Gelaround? If you don't know, the Gelaround model says "Gelaround" in the back in large letters, the regular does not. Except for the gel, they seem to be exactly the same (size, weight, styling).

Emily