Alright I ended up getting the Merrell Winterlude 6 boots in black and I LOVE them!! They were super comfy from the moment I stepped into them. The North Face McCurdo was the other one I was seriously considering but when I tried them on they really felt tight across the top of my foot. I have a super high arch and they were just too snug, even in a larger size. Plus I think I decided that a higher boot bugs me where it hit my leg higher up. I'll just get some gators to ensure no snow invades my warm, snuggly, dry feet through the top of the Merrells! Thanks to everyone for your help and advice!