I have no idea how you'd categorize these old feet, that's the insole from the new balance, but they wear:
New Balance tennies size 9 1/2, a tiny bit squished on the right
Asolo hiking boots (my favorite fit, nice tall toebox) size 9
Sidi mountain bike shoes size 42, my old Shimano shoes fit better but these are much much more sturdy.

The Sidis are a little narrow but don't really bother me when I'm on the bike. Now that they have wides I'll try those on when it comes time for new. I just hope the heel is the same as their regular ones.

Guess I'll just hop on your question wagon and see what the girl wonders have to say...