Best ones I've used have been Sugoi resistor booties.

Now I've switched to winter shoes though... If you can find a pair on sale they may actually end up being a better value (booties get worn and torn up pretty quickly and good ones cost about $50). Winter shoes are also many times better at keeping your feet warm and dry than any booties ever could be, so if you find you are spending any significant time in the wet and cold they are well worth it. Otherwise layering - sock liner, wool sock, shoe (seal the cleat holes with silicone from the inside of the shoe) and bootie is a good combo.