Hello Ladies—
I am a MTBer, in the market for my first road bike in 20 years. I’ve demo’d a handful of bikes, and recently became smitten with Trek Madone 5.1. (Yes, it’s way more bike than I “need,” but that part I can justify!) My only concern is that it has a compact crankset rather than a triple. I live in a very hilly area, and I did notice that when climbing, I was wishing for some smaller gears. I’m not sure if this is because I’m used to my MTB’s granny gears, just not used to road bikes, or if I really would be happier with a traditional triple crankset. I know Trek makes this bike in a triple, but I can’t find an 08 in my size.

Any thoughts from those who love or hate compacts? Also, is it a big deal to switch it out if I don’t like it? I read somewhere I could swap the cassette and end up with almost as many gears. Is that expensive? I’m thinking maybe I could ask the shop to do that as part of the sale. Right now, it has a 34/50 in front and 12-27 in rear.

I appreciate any input. You’ve all been a huge help already—I’ve been trolling this forum for a few weeks now and have learned so much!