DH commutes on his Specialized Expedition and seems to really like it. His ride is about 10 miles one way and hilly. He's got armadillo tires and could probably also use some slime in at least the front tube.

On the other hand, I do not like MY Expedition at all for that kind of riding. The "spongy" feeling that goes with the suspension stuff that is supposed to make it more comfortable doesn't work for me.

I like my little "ancient" hybrid Trek aside from the weight of it. I'm using it to carry stuff like groceries - sometimes with a trailer. Someday if I get more serious about that I may invest in a lighter version, but the hybrid is definitely a good choice with smooth tires. Sometimes you see "city" or touring tires with a bit more tread than road bike tires and that might be nice for if she has a gravelly ride. It can also help with the confidence we sometimes lack in those smooth tires when starting out!

(I have a Specialized Dolce saddle on the Trek. It was nice on the Expedition too)

Karen in Boise