gear questions

[grey]

If you can't exchange for a triple, you can also switch to a compact double for around $99 + labor. It's apparently a really easy switch, one I plan to make in a few months.

[bike4ever]

grey - She already has a compact double on this bike.

I agree with withm about exchanging the bike for something with a triple.

[pardes]

Thanks for the replies.

Can't I just replace the front end with something like a Shimano Deore XT M770 165mm 4 arm Crank 22-32-44 that will get me the easy gears I need? It appears they run about $260. Maybe they will take the old one for a reduced price at Bikieline?????

[Eden]

Thanks for the replies.

Can't I just replace the front end with something like a Shimano Deore XT M770 165mm 4 arm Crank 22-32-44 that will get me the easy gears I need? It appears they run about $260. Maybe they will take the old one for a reduced price at Bikieline?????

It's not that simple - your shifter has to be able to handle 3 chainrings (I'm not sure it cannot, I'd have to look it up, but I suspect that it probably will only do a double), and your bottom bracket would need to be wider and thus changed out also. If you want a triple, at this point if you can exchange the bike, that would likely be a better option. It will likely run you a fair amount of $$$ to do the complete swap.

edit - I looked it up on Shimano's web site and I think I can now say that you cannot use your current shifters with a triple front chainring. The R440 set was made specifically for a double and there is a different model for a triple.

[Becky]

That's a really nice component mix ya got there! But, with all of the loaded riding (e.g., panniers and such) that you're doing, I think that a triple is the way to go. My commuter has a triple on it, and yes, I bail out to the 30-tooth granny gear on the ride home!

By my way of thinking, you have 2 choices- new crankset, left shifter, new bottom bracket, and maybe a new front derailleur, or new bike altogether. It's really going to depend on how much you're willing to spend, and what the shop is willing to do for you (not necessarily in that order).

There are less-expensive mountain triple cranksets out there than an XT crankset that would still have a 22-tooth small ring, so you could save some money there. You'd save a little by switching just the left shifter, although you wouldn't necessarily have a matched pair then.

ADD: Are these your shifters? http://www.jensonusa.com/store/produ...+Shifters.aspx If so, it looks like they are triple-compatible, according to Jenson. That would save some coin there, although you still may need a different front derailleur.

I'd go to the shop where you bought the bike, tell them just what you posted here about wanting lower gearing, and ask them to lay out your options. Good luck, and let us know how everything goes!