Quote Originally Posted by Anathema View Post
If anything, I feel like the seat is too low. I know I'm supposed to keep some bend in my knee, and both the guy who helped fit my bike the other day and the guy who first looked over the bike when I bought it said I should keep it where it is, a bit lower than feels natural to me. Still, if it were about my own taste, I'd like just a little more extension in the down position.
It is about your own taste! It's your bike and your ride!

Put a mark on the seatpost (tape, ink, scratch, whatever makes a decent mark) where it is now, and raise that puppy up! Play with it! In the end, you might decide you liked it best where it was, so you just lower it back down to the mark you made.

It's your bike, and it's absolutely your right to fiddle with the fit. Heck, it's almost a sacred tradition to fuss and fiddle with fit.

Don't be afraid to experiment. Have fun!