Thanks everyone. I still have not yet decided which pedals to get, but today I put down a deposit on a pair of Sidi Dominator 5. I needed to replace my current pair of new MTB shoes because they were squeezing my right toes something aweful. I was warned to not try on Sidi (due to the price) but after the first 3 pair of other brand didn't feel right, I tried on the Sidis. There was no looking back. Once I found my size it was like a pair of slippers on my feet.

According to the LBS, they are compatible with any SPD-type pedal.

I'll wait until I actually have the shoes in hand before I start shopping for the pedals. I'll get those at a different LBS where they will put me on a trainer in the shoes and let me practice until I am comfortable, then ride in the street around the store.