I have plenty of room in them, that is what is weird, my toes aren't even close to the top of the shoe. They were almost loose on me when I tried them on in the store, so maybe I need to wear them around the house and stretch the sides out a little bit or something.. Thanks for the help!
The position of the clip on the bottom of your shoe may need to be adjusted. Just a thought.
The Journey is the Reward.
Sounds weird, but it could be due to the saddle too. All the spin class seats I've seen are overly plush, which can cause blood flow issues to your hands & feet. After you try moving the cleat around, as mentioned, try to get out of the saddle frequently to allow the blood flow to circulate freely. Unfortunately not a lot that can be done to change that... adding a gel cover will only make it worse.