I found more foot numbness when I was riding the wrong saddle. must have been pinching somewhere. Also, saddle adjustment would probably make a big difference there, too.

if you can wiggle your toes in your shoes, your shoes are probably not the problem.

cleat placement could be an issue for you, too.

have you had a good BS fit you on your bike yet? I get that done on my road bike in a week. I can't wait!!

Namaste,
~T~