Interesting pedal question

[KnottedYet]

My Speedplay Frogs tend to unclip before I even know I'm gonna fall, and I catch myself.

The one time they didn't (so far) I *knew* I was gonna fall and I'd already decided to take the bike with me.

[emily_in_nc]

I came unclipped automatically from Speedplay X-2s during my serious accident in 2005 but never came unclipped during normal riding.

When I first started using Speedplay Frogs this year on my mtb, I noticed that I occasionally came unclipped during normal riding. I was used to Eggbeaters Candies, which I found too difficult to clip into on rooty singletrack, which is why the change in pedals. Once I ironed out my pedaling style, it got much less sloppy, and I no longer clip out accidentally from my Frogs. But as easy as they are to get out of, I am sure I'd clip out automatically in a fall (haven't fallen with them yet - knock wood). My mtb buddy has taken a couple really minor slow-speed tumbles this summer and has ended up still clipped in to her Eggbeaters.

Just a bit of data....

Emily

[lph]

I was wondering about the same thing. When I went airborne from my mtb a few weeks ago I was definitely unclipped from my spds, but have no recollection of doing so on purpose. I may have just done it automatically, maybe they released by themselves.

But I keep my spds (Shimano, forget the model) on pretty light tension, and have never been able to accidentally unclip just by pulling hard on them (which I do, quite often), so I always figured I had to do the sideways twist to get my foot out. I've had another, worn pair that unclipped while using them though - very scary!

[Andrea]

I have a fun clipless story from my weekend cyclocross adventure-

I watched a CX race on Saturday and decided it looked like fun, so I bought some MTB shoes, put some clipless spd pedals on my mountain bike (it previously wore toe clips), and spent about and hour learning how to dismount & remount. It was difficult- since the pedals were brand new (and I was used to speedplay road pedals), they were very difficult to clip in & out of.
The next day, while warming up, I was approaching a barrier at speeds much greater than what I'd practiced the day before, and, as I tried to dismount, my left foot didn't unclip, and I went somersaulting into the mud in front of the barrier! Somewhere during my gymnastics, my left foot did unclip, however, I'm not sure at which point during the rotation it did so.
I made it a point to exaggerate the unclipping motion during all other dismounts, and didn't have any more problems