i agree. keep the boots.

mine are 15 yrs old and in need of replacement, but i'm hanging onto them (not that i'd be able to sell them for much) to get me by until i start riding more again. if i had new ones, i for sure would be keeping them! cycling really hasn't affected my calf size, because they are pretty much always one of my skinniest parts. i bet you could still make them fit down the road.

the price keeps going up too, so it'd be tougher to get new ones later if you sold these.