Did you replace the saddle that came on your last bike

[skyhand]

saddle that came with my bike didn't work well for me. bought a brooks B-17 and it was comfortable right outta the box. had to adjust the tilt some, but now it's perfect. finally breaking in too!

[RoadRaven]

I voted "yes, straight away".

I have a saddle I like, so I have put the same saddle on each of my bikes... buying a new one of the same brand for each extra pony in my stable

[SouthernBelle]

I voted yes, straight away, but it was really yes after a while.

[Trek420]

1st road bike - changed from what came with to Avocet, when that wore out Terry, when that one wore out back to Avocet, Terry again, to a Sella Italia Lady gel which was love at first sit. I hope it wore out the parts of the &*^% who stole it

2nd road bike - specified the Sella Italia Lady Gel which is current fave

commutermobile - rode the cheap cheap cheap worthless POS cheap saddle into the ground because .... I liked it! When it completely wore down to the foam rubber .... it got the old Sella off road bike.

The freewheel - my LBS picked the Avocet because he knows it's one I like.

[sgtiger]

The only items I kept from my old bike, when I went to my current set-up, was the Frogs and the Brooks B-72. It took me years to find a saddle that works for me, so I decided to go with that than even try the saddle that came spec'd with my bike. My bum is happy.

[boy in a kilt]

I've never had a stock saddle that I really liked all that much although my Davidson came close. It had a saddle that very closely resembled the old Selle Italia Turbo. That was my favorite saddle until I could actually afford a brooks.

Extra points for the retro grouches. Does anyone remember the old Lon Haldeman Brooks ads in Bicycling? I know a couple of you do.

When I bought my Trek, I went through quite a few saddles, including a couple of the anatomic models with cut outs and padding in various places. I think the most painful one was the Specialized anatomic model.

[VeloVT]

I replaced the saddles on both bikes fairly quickly. It took me a few experiments to get it right but I found a saddle I really like (Fizik Arione) and now have it on both bikes.

BiK, funny you should mention the Specialized saddle as a source of particular agony. I don't know which model you tried -- but it seems to be such a popular saddle. However, my bf has a Specialized Alias right now, and neither of us are wild about it. I will say that it's light years better than my first experiment after discarding the Bontrager that came on my road bike though -- the Terry Damselfly. Not the right saddle for me at all!

[elk]

I'm a freak.
I changed my stock Specialized saddle even though it was comfortable...I had my heart set on a Brooks...

[boy in a kilt]

BiK, funny you should mention the Specialized saddle as a source of particular agony. I don't know which model you tried -- but it seems to be such a popular saddle. However, my bf has a Specialized Alias right now, and neither of us are wild about it. I will say that it's light years better than my first experiment after discarding the Bontrager that came on my road bike though -- the Terry Damselfly. Not the right saddle for me at all!

I think it was an earlier incarnation fo the Alias. I vaugely remember trying another saddle of that sort. Men's Liberator I think.

It may be that I tend to sit forward on my saddles so the sides of the cut-outs applied very focused pressure on my perineum.

[teawoman]

Well, I was expecting to have to replace mine, but I have gone 50k with no problems. It's a Selle Royal Viper for Women on a Giant OCR 1

[KnottedYet]

Love my Brooks B67. Each of my bikes has one. Bliss for my butt.