Darn. Mine will be too small for you then . . .

jcorbiser had a good suggestion re REI, which is where I got my PI shoes for $29.99 (the previous year's model, regularly $90 or so). They have 20% deals a few times a year as well, which is when you can get a good deal on the pedals. If you do decide to buy over the internet, make sure you try on the same size/brand/style before you make your purchase so as to make sure they feel good on your feet.

Sizing really depends on brand - my PI's are a size 36 and are too big (slip in the heel). My new Sidi's are 38's and fit like a glove. I wear anywhere from a 5.5 to 6.5 in street shoes.

Good luck to you!