I use Looks for now. I also have some Speedplay Frogs I need to put on my bike.

I started with SPDs. I was ok with them but once I used the Looks, I didn't like the SPDs anymore. The spin bikes I use in class have SPD pedals so I do have cycling shoes with SPD cleats.

I don't have the kind of pedals you're talking about but sometimes it takes a while to find out what you like. I do like the idea of a wider pedal base, it makes pedaling SO much easier when you're starting out. There are times that I don't clip in at all if I know I'm coming up to another stop in less than a few minutes.

Good luck