Tucker - I do have a Bontrager saddle. I am going to put a Specialized saddle on the bike and see what happens.
Thanks for all your help everyone!
You shouldn't feel bruised or injured by your saddle, whether it's on a road bike, hybrid, mountain, unicycle, WHATEVER.
Put your old saddle on the new bike, and just see how it feels. Wear your favorite shorts and see if that makes it even better.
It's a place to start.
Then come back and tell us how it goes. We've all been through the what saddle/what shorts/what lube/what placement fandango, and we're full of ideas!
"If Americans want to live the American Dream, they should go to Denmark." - Richard Wilkinson
The saddle that made my bottom happy on my "hybrid" comfort bike was a bummer on my road bike -- the sit position is so very different...
I am doing pretty well with my Specialized Ariel that's a bit narrower than the saddle that I had on my old bike -- so far, anyway, and as long as I wear the thinner chamois. Oh, and the smaller ones rather than the ones that my measurements and the ones on the sizing charts say should fit!
Karen in Boise