I agree with giving the Scott one more effort and then selling it if it isn't a cheap fix.

My S.O. has a 2002 Jamis Quest. It's a great bike. We both have Jamis mountain bikes. I have nothing but good things to say about their bikes (and their prices).

Way off topic... I must comment on your name and avatar... I have 2 collies, a tri smooth and a rough blue merle. They're wonderful dogs aren't they?