I have a Felt F70, and I love her! When I picked her out, I also tried a Scott Speedster and I personally did not like it. It was simply too stiff. When I hit a bump, it felt like my whole body was going to explode, whereas Athena just glided over bumps and holes making me feel all comfy-like! So, I ended up with the Felt. The thing is...both are great bikes. Scott makes some great machines, it just was not my cup of tea.

Good luck making a choice!