I have different pairs for differents hikes. I've got boots for when I'm carrying a heavy pack (30-40 lbs.) and other boots for light packs. And, I found out on my 17 mile days that I mistakenly brought my 7-mile shoes! Seriously, my Lowa's are my 'go-to' shoes for hikes with a light pack, but I forgot that after about 8 miles, I start to feel every little rock and pebble under my foot. I have an old pair of Zamberlain's for heavy-pack or long-distance dayhikes - I love them. They used to be a pretty shade of blue, now they're just kinda brown.
You really need to try them on, and determine how much weight you're going to carry. Even trail conditions - easy, maintained trails and you can get away with a lower cut. Rocky, unmaintained trails and you might want something with good ankle support.
For 3 days, I get to part of a thousand other journeys.