Thanks for all your comments and advice. I'll look into the Brooks. I definitely need to ask my LBS if I can try out saddles, or at least sit on some at the shop, on my bike. One of the reasons I was going to try a Terry is because of their 30 day return policy. I didn't know Brooks had an even better one. That's cool. Of course, at REI you can return anything any time for any reason for forever! So, that's an option too.

I don't really know if my sit bones are considered wide, I just assume so since I do seem to be "hippy". Small waist, big hips. I'll look up the threads on measuring my sit bones. Yet, I hear that even some people with wide sit bones prefer smaller saddles, so what is one to do other than try lots of saddles?! Could this be any more confusing?!