SadieKate and Robyn, I knew there would have to be someone out there with feet like mine that could give me some guidance. I think I'll order a pair of 38's and a pair of 38.5's. The TE size chart would have put me in a 37.5, but after hearing everyone talk about them running small, I was afraid to order without some input from someone with clones of my feet. Unfortunately, there is no store anywhere near me that has any to try on.

Mind if I ask what pedals you've paired them with?