New Pedals

[sarahfixit]

Make sure your shoe cleats are tight on the shoes.
Pull the pedals and apply a light coating of grease, any kind really, on the threads. Tighten forcefully.(I can actually say that here without the bodybuilders ).
I would also put on some chain lube where the cleat engages the pedal.

That should do it unless there is something more serious, like the crankset bolts.

[bikerchick68]

hiya... weird... I had this same issue not long ago... had a odd clicking noise that started at the same time I got new shoes and moved my cleats onto them... I did everything I could think of only to find out that coincidentally, the bottom bracket had begun creaking at the same time... had the LBS clean and re-lube the bottom bracket and no more creak... go figure the two things happened at the same time... Murphy's law... yep, Murphy hates me!

good luck with it...