Well, the doctor says that my problems stem from my over-pronation (worse in the right foot) and that going with an arch support insole was the right idea. Unfortunately, it was too narrow for my foot. So, I've agreed to a custom orthotic. Does $400 sound like a decent price? With my insurance apparently it's about 50-50 whether they'll cover the cost. If they won't, I guess that's why I have a medical flexible spending account. My feet and health are worth it.