Knott here, too lazy to switch login from Trek:
I sing 2nd alto. Can't read music unless I'm playing an instrument, so I get parked next to another 2nd alto and told to "sing with her." Works for me!
SKnot has perfect pitch and an amazing voice and musical memory, but refuses to sing in a group. Bummer.
Trek here, I know I know very confusing but now this is actually me, really.
I sang soprano, or maybe I was mezzo soprano in HS choir. Although I no longer play (flute) I had (have still?) perfect pitch, a good ear anyway.
My (and Duck On Wheels also) brother is a gifted musician too, check it out at:
http://whassuppussycat.com/