Colby, have you tried Saucony shoes? I also have wide feet with average-width heels, and Sauconies always fit. Although Asics makes great shoes, they just don't fit those of us with wider feet. The Saucony model that is comparable to the Asics 2100 (which both of my running partners wear and swear by, but they have "normal" feet) is the Grid Omni, which is offered in a wide width and two stability options. I wear the "moderate stability" version and really like it. The Hurricane is also a good shoe, but is a bit heavier and more controlling. Just another option to consider.

KB