chickwhorips - I had the surgery 5+ years ago. They did the 5th and 1st met at the same time. I did it definitely during the winter since it was an 8 week recovery. Like you, I was in way too much pain. I am so glad I had the surgery. My foot no longer hurts (unless I have injured it). I still am quite careful about the shoes I choose even though my width decreased some. Please let me know if you have any questions. I figure I've been there.