I own a Trek 1000, however I did test ride the two bikes you are deciding between. Everyone is different. I really liked the Trek Pilot 1.0 and it was a tough call between that and my Trek 1000. I did not care for the Giant, but again, it is such an individual preference. I tried the 1000, well I do not know why, I thought I wanted to be more uporight, yet tried the 1000 determined to hate it and as soon as I rode her it felt as though she always belonged with me.

Which do you feel most comfortable on? Whichever you chose is a good choice, as long as you feel good on it.