quint41:

As I just posted, I ended up getting a Trek Pilot 2.1 (non-WSD). I have long arms and big hands so the reach and shifting are not a problem (as long as I know in what direction I should be shifting, that is!).

Good luck. Keep testing and sleep on it. Although I didn't experience the "aha" or "I must have this bike" reaction, I am very happy with my new ride. And I'm also glad that I could purchase it at my local bike shop where I trust the mechanic's advice.