Road riding falls

[ccnyc]

4 Sideways low speed tip over's for me, but I was clipped out (right foot) each time.

First: On the walkway of the George Washington Bridge at the really narrow part of the walkway, I clipped out (right side) because I was letting some other riders go by me. I reached for the railing of the bridge (on my right) to steady myself and because the railing was so wide I couldn't get a good grip, my hand slipped off and I fell over on my left, clipped in side... in front of lots of other riders. I practically bounced back up off the ground I was so embarassed.

Second: Coming to a stop at the bottom of a not very steep hill I put my unclipped right foot down and my metal cleat (Speedplay Zero's) slipped on the pavement and I went down, sliding maybe a few feet. My first road rash.

Third: Waiting at a stop sign, right foot unclipped, chatting with my husband (on my right) I lost my balance and tipped over to the left. More road rash, but my Shebeest tights had no damage whatsoever.

Fourth: Struggling up a very, very steep hill that I had never done before I realized that I couldn't turnover the pedals anymore. I got my right foot unclipped, no problem, but fell to the left. Road rash and feeling sorry for myself were the results. Oh, I even had a couple low gears left and I would have most likely made it up the hill. I guess my brain just took a vacation for a few moments!

Carol

[EvilTwin]

Three decidedly ungraceful clipless falls: first one was the first day with my new bike. I had practiced clipping in and out at the house, so BF and I set out. Get to the first intersection, and oops... I can't get my foot out. Oh f****... Bf looks back to see me topple over just as the SUV comes up to the stop sign. No scrapes/bruises... made it ok the rest of the ride, and after we fininshed, we looked at my pedals and realized they could be adjusted to be easier... duh.
2nd time was similar, but 2 months into riding...slowed and unclipped for an intersection, saw a car, then decided I had room to go... unfortunately, I was off balance and when I tried to pedal, I just fell over. BF again hears me swear just as the car comes up.... dumb. Third time was the next day at a stop sign. Unclipped left, went to put right foot on the curb, and missed.... promptly fell again. With cars as an audience again.... That's it so far.... I'm sure there'll be more!

[BleeckerSt_Girl]

Wow, so in this poll so far, 70% of all falls were "sideways lo-speed tip-overs" and from reading, it seems almost all of these were from being clipped in.
Hmmm....
Think I'll continue avoiding those clipless thingys for a while yet!
Gonna put my PowerGrip straps on soon- I think they may be way easier for me to get in and out of in a hurry.

I couldn't vote yet because I haven't fallen yet in my first two months of riding. I did skid on gravel a bit though- and hopped off my saddle only far enough to come down right on my tailbone on the saddle horn- AGhhhhh!!!!
Still healing a week later- but it was not a fall!

[SadieKate]

Ah, Lisa, you are jumping to the conclusion that clipless guarantees a fall. Before you make the decision to stay clipless you need to set up a poll about the benefits outweighing the cons of clipless. There must be some reason so many of us use them.

[DebW]

Ah, Lisa, you are jumping to the conclusion that clipless guarantees a fall. Before you make the decision to stay clipless you need to set up a poll about the benefits outweighing the cons of clipless. There must be some reason so many of us use them.

Clipless were invented because they are far safer and easier and quicker to use than their predecessor: cleated shoes with clips and straps. Those were so dangerous that most recreational riders didn't use them, and thus missed the benefits of pulling up and back on the pedals. Most riders who used them learned how to do trackstands because getting in and out at every stop light was really annoying. Unfortunately, I never learned the trackstand. See my post in this thread of my one tip-over fall three decades ago. Compared to that system, clipless are HEAVENLY! In many a panic stop with clipless pedals, I've always gotten out in time.

[kaybee]

I voted. I'm a slow-speed tipper overer, and have matching scars on my knees to prove it.

KB

[BleeckerSt_Girl]

Oh I am sure that clipless have MANY wonderful benefits!
However, as a new rider who doesn't have a great sense of balance and confidence yet, I feel I want to get surer on my bike before I try that sort of thing. I also think clipless may not make the best sense when riding in low speed town/traffic situations where you have to stop, start, or weave and where cars are making unexpected moves all around you. At least not for me.

I admit it gives me the shivers when I read posts about new riders who have only been riding a couple of weeks falling over at stop lights and intersections while practicing clipless AND learning to ride at the same time.